GLP-1 GI injuries: the gastric emptying ruling
MDL 3094 · E.D. Pa. · Judge Karen Spencer Marston · Decided August 15, 2025
The question
Can gastroparesis be diagnosed without a gastric emptying study?
Plaintiffs’ experts
Dr. Daniel L. Raines (gastroenterology) and Dr. Eliot L. Siegel (radiology). Both were excluded.
Defense expert
Dr. Linda Nguyen (gastroenterology and motility). Reporting on the ruling says her testimony was accepted as consistent with medical guidelines.
Why Raines failed
The court found the studies he cited didn’t support his central opinion that retained food proves delayed emptying; his time window moved from one week to one month to five weeks to three months; and at deposition he agreed his method seemed circular.
Why Siegel failed
Published coverage reports he couldn’t point to literature supporting imaging as a substitute for a gastric emptying study, and that his description of the technique shifted between subjective and objective.
The defense expert’s angle
Her opinion tracked the 2022 gastroparesis guideline she co-authored. That guideline’s conflict disclosure lists her as a consultant to Eli Lilly, a defendant, among other companies.
for expert vetting
Opinions that track published clinical guidelines tend to survive; opinions that stretch the cited studies past what their authors said tend not to. When an opposing expert’s method is guideline-consistent, bias is often the better line of cross.