Explore capabilities →

Case studies

Five real expert fights.

From MDLs in the app. Each summary is drawn from the court’s ruling or published coverage of it, linked below each case.

GLP-1 GI injuries: the gastric emptying ruling

MDL 3094 · E.D. Pa. · Judge Karen Spencer Marston · Decided August 15, 2025

The question

Can gastroparesis be diagnosed without a gastric emptying study?

Plaintiffs’ experts

Dr. Daniel L. Raines (gastroenterology) and Dr. Eliot L. Siegel (radiology). Both were excluded.

Defense expert

Dr. Linda Nguyen (gastroenterology and motility). Reporting on the ruling says her testimony was accepted as consistent with medical guidelines.

Why Raines failed

The court found the studies he cited didn’t support his central opinion that retained food proves delayed emptying; his time window moved from one week to one month to five weeks to three months; and at deposition he agreed his method seemed circular.

Why Siegel failed

Published coverage reports he couldn’t point to literature supporting imaging as a substitute for a gastric emptying study, and that his description of the technique shifted between subjective and objective.

The defense expert’s angle

Her opinion tracked the 2022 gastroparesis guideline she co-authored. That guideline’s conflict disclosure lists her as a consultant to Eli Lilly, a defendant, among other companies.

What it means
for expert vetting

Opinions that track published clinical guidelines tend to survive; opinions that stretch the cited studies past what their authors said tend not to. When an opposing expert’s method is guideline-consistent, bias is often the better line of cross.

Paraquat: the only causation expert

MDL 3004 · S.D. Ill. · Chief Judge Nancy J. Rosenstengel · Decided April 17, 2024

The question

Can paraquat exposure cause Parkinson’s disease?

Plaintiffs’ expert

Dr. Martin T. Wells, a Cornell statistician and epidemiologist, and plaintiffs’ sole general-causation expert. Excluded.

Why he failed

Published summaries report he started from 36 studies but meta-analyzed only seven, using a “holistic” selection the court found lacked objective criteria, and that his conclusion conflicted with the scientific consensus.

The consequence

With no admissible general-causation expert, the court granted summary judgment in the four trial-selection cases.

What it means
for expert vetting

A single causation expert is a single point of failure. In meta-analysis testimony, how studies were chosen is often the whole case; ask for the selection rules before the results.

Zantac: general causation fails in federal court

MDL 2924 · S.D. Fla. · Judge Robin L. Rosenberg · Decided December 6, 2022

The question

Did ranitidine cause cancer?

The ruling

All of plaintiffs’ general-causation experts were excluded, and summary judgment followed for the defendants.

The state-court echo

On July 10, 2025, the Delaware Supreme Court reversed a state trial court that had admitted similar expert testimony.

What it means
for expert vetting

A federal exclusion travels. Defense teams cite it in parallel state cases, and plaintiffs need experts whose methods can survive the same critique in every forum.

J&J talc: two causation fights, years apart

MDL 2738 · D.N.J. · Judge Michael A. Shipp

2020 ruling

According to J&J’s announcement, the court limited plaintiffs’ asbestos testing expert Dr. William Longo and barred Dr. Ghassan Saed from testifying that his experiments showed talc can cause ovarian cancer.

January 20, 2026

A Special Master recommended letting plaintiffs’ experts testify to a causal link between genital talc use and ovarian cancer, while excluding heavy-metal, fragrance, and inhalation theories. It’s a recommendation for Judge Shipp to adopt or reject.

May 2026

Plaintiffs’ specific-causation experts, gynecologic oncologists Drs. Judith Wolf and Daniel Clarke-Pearson, were challenged at a Rule 702 hearing. A magistrate judge then ordered all plaintiffs to show cause why their claims shouldn’t be dismissed.

What it means
for expert vetting

Winning general causation doesn’t finish the fight. Specific-causation experts get the same scrutiny, and the amended Rule 702 gave courts a reason to reopen earlier rulings.

Roundup: shaky but admissible

MDL 2741 · N.D. Cal. · Judge Vince Chhabria · Decided July 10, 2018

The question

Does glyphosate cause non-Hodgkin lymphoma?

The ruling

The court let three plaintiffs’ experts testify, calling the evidence rather weak but not junk science, and excluded some others.

Who testified

Plaintiffs’ experts at the March 2018 hearing included epidemiologist Dr. Beate Ritz and pathologist Dr. Dennis Weisenburger.

What it means
for expert vetting

Admissible isn’t the same as strong. An expert who survives Rule 702 with a “shaky” label still carries weaknesses into trial, which is where a sourced cross outline earns its keep.

Get started

Start with one capability. Connect the rest when you need them.

Use a capability on its own, or connect all five so every answer starts from what the others found. Your team works in the site; your AI agents reach the same capabilities over MCP.